The main
objective of this paper is to present a unified view on Winnicott’s contribution
to psychoanalysis. Part I (Sections 1-4) starts by recalling that, according
to some distinguished commentators, Winnicott introduced a paradigm change
in psychoanalysis. In order to show that this change can be interpreted as
a “paradigm switch” in the sense of Th. S. Kuhn, I give an account of the
Kuhnian view of science and offer a reconstruction of the Freudian Oedipal,
Triangular or “Toddler-in-the-Mother’s-Bed” Paradigm. In the Part II (Sections
5-13) it is shown that already in the 20’s Winnicott found unsupportable
anomalies in the Oedipal paradigm and, for that reason, started what may
be called revolutionary research for a new framework of psychoanalysis. This
research ended by Winnicott producing, especially during the last period
of his life, an alternative Dual or “Baby-on-the-Mother’s-Lap” Paradigm.
This new paradigm is described in some detail, especially the paradigmatic
dual mother-baby relation and Winnicott’s dominant theory of maturation.
Final remarks are dedicated to questions of Winnicott’s heritage and the
future of psychoanalysis.
Key words: paradigm, Freud, Oedipal Paradigm,
Winnicott, “Baby-on-the-Mother’s-Lap” Paradigm.
|